Featured Posts

Best Games of 2011 So Tomass rightly suggested that we run an article on our favorite games, video and otherwise. I like this suggestion a lot. Made me think long and hard about games and such, what I play and I what...

Read more

Best TV of 2011 Last week we covered the Best in Movies for 2011 (well, genre stuff, anyways). This week, we'll look at some our favorite TV from 2011. I say we, in hopes that the other boys will pitch in as well.     Admin_Rock This...

Read more

Action Smackdown FINAL: Indy vs. Bond ACTION SMACKDOWN!     It's Finals Day, and everyone is excited and eager!!!! No more delays, time for Dr Jones and James Bond to get it on.Two men enter, one man leaves.     Admin_Rock This...

Read more

Action Smackdown Semi Final 1: Indiana Jones vs The... ACTION SMACKDOWN! Semi Final 1: Indy vs TMWNN. Let's get it on like the original Red Dawn. Cub Reporter Keith Welcome back, Action Fans! This week we get one step closer to the final...

Read more

Best Sci-Fi/Comic/Genre Film of 2011:Poll Hey kids, Happy New Year and all that jazz. I'm back from vacation in Palm Springs and Mesa, and ready to get going for another year. I see everything went smoothly in my absence... What? No Action Smackdown...

Read more

Correctness

Busting a Move

Posted by admin_rock | Posted in Correctness | Posted on 19-12-2009

Tags: , ,

10

Dear Young M.C. :

RE: “Your best friend Harry has a brother Larry, and in five days from now he’s going to marry. He’s hoping you can make it, if you can, ’cause in the ceremony you’ll be the best man.”

Are we to assume that it is Harry that is going to marry? This makes more sense than the alternative, in which you are the Best Man at your best friend’s brother’s wedding. In that hypothesis, one would think Harry himself a more likely candidate. But, no, we need to assume that it is your best friend Harry whom is to wed.

This still leaves us with some concerns. Why bother interject about his brother? If Harry is your best friend, can’t we assume you’d know about the existence of Larry? Why would someone feel the need to share that fact with you. And it seems odd to place that sidenote in the context of information concerning a wedding.

Also, Harry doesn’t seem to be very good at wedding planning. A mere five days before the ceremony, there is still some question as to whether you’ll even be attending. It seems risky to be tentative about such an important role. Of course, one assumes that Larry could step in, if need be.